Fractional Ownership can be defined as the collective ownership of an asset,
usually one with a high monetary value. Usage of the asset is normally allocated
to the shareholders (owners) by means of an ownership usage roster and running
costs are divided amongst the shareholders.
Fractional ownership is one of the fastest growing leisure real
estate trends in the world and has been catching on in Southern Africa over the
past year or two.
Fractional ownership of real estate in SA is relatively new, most probably 3 years
at most, yet the concept of joint ownership has been with us for a long time.
In SA the concept and terminology "syndication" is very well known and
used. Syndication of leisure properties, specifically game farms has been structured
in syndications for years, yet it was predominantly done by friends and family.
The complication of such "friendly" syndications is that no formal exit
method exists and when a member of the syndication wants to exit the structure,
pressure occurs. The value of the syndication comes into play as well as the criteria
for who may enter as the substitute member. Typically the management of the syndication
could also be a burden on some of the members.
We see fractional ownership as a suitable ownership structure becoming one of
the most frequently used methods of acquiring and owning lifestyle holiday properties
in South Africa.
The reason for this view is based on a few underlying factors that could fuel
such a market shift. These factors being:
- The increase in secondary luxury properties has rocketed over the past few
years.
- These secondary homes are now in most instances worth more than primary residences.
- Full ownership of such a valuable but underutilized asset could mean an overly
"leisure" weighted investment structure.
- The rise in these property prices did not go hand in hand with an equal rise
in the spending power of the owners.
- High levels of "speculative" investors in lifestyle resorts who
now own vacant land and very little secondary demand.
- Fractional ownership is a method of creating lower barriers of entry into
the leisure market.
- The concept balances use with cost.
Confusing terminology
Fractional ownership is the method of acquiring and owning a share
or portion of a property and having an agreed usage system of the property and
the responsibility of the cost associated with that portion.
Fractionals is the portion that a shareholder owns, typically 4 to 8 weeks per
annum.
Fractions is the week that the owner owns.
Private residence is the dwelling or residence, typically furnished to the highest
standards inclusive of luxury appliances, destinations toys and some customised
luxuries.
Private residence clubs is a structure to accommodate the use and exchange of
use between the owners of fractions in various Private Residences.
Private residence company is the shelf company that owns the property, and in
which shares are bought.
Industries prone to fractional ownership
Fractionals today are used in a wide range of industry. Aircraft, jet, yachts,
boats, homes, vacation homes, condos, hotels, apartments and real estate. An opportunity
was recently offered to buy a fraction of
.metal then being kept in safe
custody in a London vault!
The use
Ownerships of fractionals give the owners exclusive access to this property for
the set term, or interval owned on a perpetual basis. In South Africa the most
fractionals are structured according to a usage roster, which could vary from
a "week in every season" to clusters of weeks every year, or 2 weeks
in the first part of the year and 2 weeks in the later part of the year. Some
providers offer the fractions as a set number of weeks or days per annum but with
no defined time of use.Similarly fractionals are offered in two basic methods
of use in private residences, either with no exchange which means you can only
use your own Private Residence, or alternatively you own a specific unit, but
you can use any of the similar units, be it in the same or in a different resort
or destination.
How many fractions to a property?
Fractions vary substantially, but shared interests generally
begin at 1/26 of a year (14 days) and go up. Annual intervals can be 1/26 (14
day) or 1/12 of a year (30 days) 1/13 of a year (28 Days), 1/8 of a year (45 Days)
to as long as you want. Two weeks annually to a month annually, to 6 weeks or
more on an annual basis.We found that the combination of the destination and the
product should be the determinant of the fraction number and not a set rule.
In the Kalahari a client would seek a maximum of 2 weeks, whereas
a Golf resort close to Gauteng would be better suited to a higher frequency of
use and thus a lesser number of fractions.Traditionally 12 fractions implied 4
unused weeks which was then reserved or used as maintenance weeks, however this
is not always as functional and maintenance is done as and when required.
Is fractional ownership timeshare?
Fractional ownership shares some attributes with timeshare in
that multiple people use the same property with a defined usage agreement, that's
where the similarity ends.
Fractional ownership is underpinned by property ownership, it is a real right,
either in an undivided share of the property, or through a share in a private
company which owns the property.
Timeshare is a "right of use" with no property ownership.
Who buys into fractional ownership?
With the industry still in its formative phases it wouldn't be
accurate to define the exact profile of a typical buyer, however we have found
a number of attributes that may identify the most likely buyer.
- People with an established primary residence
- Aspiring wealthy
- Financially educated
- 30 Plus age group
- Decision is driven by the husband in families
- Multiracial profile
Finance of fractionals
Finance of fractional ownership is still a grey area as the commercial
banks in South Africa are still assessing the potential, the demographics and
the most suitable structures. Some providers offer a structure where the Private
Residence in question is bonded and the different shareholders pay their respective
portions. In the instance of Shareblock Companies this is however much more difficult.Finance
offered through some of the niche banks is more reliant on the profile of the
buyer, where the overall position is assessed and the sharecertificate is but
one of a few assets in the client's portfolio.
Structure of ownership
A host of different structures are currently on offer all offering
property ownership, ranging from undivided shares in the property direct, shares
in a private company that owns the property, shares in a private company that
owns a number of Private Residences, or shares in a Share block company.
The share block being the most onerous structure for the fractional company, but
offering the best protection to its investors.
Exchange programs
Two schools of thought exist on this aspect.
The purists who believe that fractional ownership is a simulation of owning your
own private holiday home, customised to your needs and reflecting your own personal
touch. (This is where the extreme value added service of having your own family
pictures hung on your visit applies) These clients want absolute no resemblance
to timeshare, with no other people thus occupying their residence, and no desire
to use someone else's house.The inverse group want the best of both worlds.
Ownership of a specific residence, with the knowledge and expectation
of its growth and scarcity value, combined with the flexibility to use an alternative
as and when needed.We initially anticipated that the market will predominantly
be purists, but however that was proven wrong! The majority of clients and interested
parties would like an exchange program to be linked to the product.
Concept structure
The fractional ownership market in South Africa has 3 distinct components:
- Product identification conceptualisation and development.
- Intermediary marketing and sales
- Operational management
- It is not necessary to be active in all three stages to participate in the
market, only true vertically integrated companies would do so
|